Skip to main content
Independent · not a government site

1952 term · Vinson Court · 4-4

Harrison, Collector of Internal Revenue, v. Bohnen, Executor, et al.

345 U.S. 946 · 73 S. Ct. 863 · 1953 U.S. LEXIS 2690

The record

Term
1952
Decided
Issue area
Vote split
4-4
Winning party
Unclear
Decision direction
Chief Justice
Vinson Court
Disposition
Affirmed
Docket
566
U.S. Reports
345 U.S. 946
S. Ct. citation
73 S. Ct. 863
LEXIS citation
1953 U.S. LEXIS 2690

How the bench divided

8 not participating? 1 no vote recorded

The per-justice record for this case is incomplete: it accounts for 0 of the 8 votes in the reported 4-4 split.

How each justice voted in Harrison, Collector of Internal Revenue, v. Bohnen, Executor, et al.
JusticeVote
Fred M. VinsonNo participation
Hugo BlackNo participation
Stanley ReedNo participation
Felix FrankfurterNo participation
William O. DouglasNo participation
Harold BurtonNo participation
Tom C. ClarkNo participation
Sherman MintonNo participation
Robert H. JacksonUnknown